Forum der Vereinigung der Sternfreunde
https://forum.vdsastro.de/

My attempt at WR134
https://forum.vdsastro.de/viewtopic.php?t=4017
Seite 1 von 1

Autor:  John Strachan [ 25. Juli 2013, 16:46:08 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Attached 2 one hour exposures of WR134 taken last nightf with Mewlon 250 at F12 with LHIRES III and 1200 grating from Villeveyrac France

Lots of clouds interrupted the exposures - hoping for better weather tonight.

cheers

John

Dateianhänge:
wr134firstattempt.PNG
wr134firstattempt.PNG [ 10.86 KiB | 11923 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  John Strachan [ 26. Juli 2013, 16:04:21 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  Last nights wr134

Three more exposures from WR134 from last night red,then green, then blue - one hour exposure for each before the clouds completely set in.

Dateianhänge:
WR134Thu25thResults.PNG
WR134Thu25thResults.PNG [ 28.3 KiB | 11892 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Tony Moffat [ 26. Juli 2013, 16:52:11 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Wow, that?s a pretty weird (but interesting if real) profile with very strong central hump. It should disappear (or move off the centre) at some point, e.g. another night. It?s probably due to a co-rotating arm stretching out in the wind. Keep on observing, please!

Best, Tony

From: John Strachan (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 10:04 AM
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Three more exposures from WR134 from last night red,then green, then blue - one hour exposure for each before the clouds completely set in.

Autor:  Robin Leadbeater [ 26. Juli 2013, 17:50:32 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi Tony,

It seems to be a recurring feature, eg see 20130715

Robin


----- Original Message ----- From: Tony Moffat (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 4:03 PM
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134



Wow, that?s a pretty weird (but interesting if real) profile with very strong central hump. It should disappear (or move off the centre) at some point, e.g. another night. It?s probably due to a co-rotating arm stretching out in the wind. Keep on observing, please!

Best, Tony

From: John Strachan (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))
Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 10:04 AM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Three more exposures from WR134 from last night red,then green, then blue - one hour exposure for each before the clouds completely set in.



Tony Moffat

Dateianhänge:
WR134_THO_20130712-15-18.png
WR134_THO_20130712-15-18.png [ 27.34 KiB | 11889 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Tony Moffat [ 26. Juli 2013, 18:12:43 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi Robin:

Possibly even on the presumed rotation period of 2.3d....? The coherency is not great in this star, though, especially over intervals longer than a few rotations. But with our incredibly long run we should be able to get a much better handle on this! Thanks for showing the repeated hump.

Cheers, Tony

From: Robin Leadbeater (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 11:54 AM
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi Tony,

It seems to be a recurring feature, eg see 20130715

Robin


----- Original Message ----- From: Tony Moffat (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))
Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 4:03 PM
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134



Wow, that?s a pretty weird (but interesting if real) profile with very strong central hump. It should disappear (or move off the centre) at some point, e.g. another night. It?s probably due to a co-rotating arm stretching out in the wind. Keep on observing, please!

Best, Tony

From: John Strachan (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))
Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 10:04 AM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Three more exposures from WR134 from last night red,then green, then blue - one hour exposure for each before the clouds completely set in.



Tony Moffat

Autor:  John Strachan [ 27. Juli 2013, 16:31:40 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  WR134 from 26th

Only one decent spectra from last night due to clouds rolling in :0(. And big central peak has gone/moved bluewards perhaps....

Dateianhänge:
WR134Fri26thResults.PNG
WR134Fri26thResults.PNG [ 16.9 KiB | 11858 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Tony Moffat [ 29. Juli 2013, 00:14:47 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Yes, I would say probably moved bluewards. This probably is related to the 2.3d rotation period, but of course we?ll have to look at the whole 4 months of data before we know really how coherent this variation is. That?s of course one of the goals of the campaign, at least for this star. Lovely work!

Tony

From: John Strachan (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Saturday, July 27, 2013 10:31 AM
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Only one decent spectra from last night due to clouds rolling in :0(. And big central peak has gone/moved bluewards perhaps....

Autor:  John Strachan [ 30. Juli 2013, 12:15:24 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  Monday night results

Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak

Dateianhänge:
WR134-130729.PNG
WR134-130729.PNG [ 17.49 KiB | 11791 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  thierry Garrel [ 31. Juli 2013, 04:22:16 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan <fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)>
Zitat:
Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak






Dateianhänge:
ew_courbe.png
ew_courbe.png [ 3.9 KiB | 11773 mal betrachtet ]
multiplot.WR134_5411.png
multiplot.WR134_5411.png [ 10.8 KiB | 11773 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Robin Leadbeater [ 31. Juli 2013, 12:01:55 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi Thierry,

The 2D intensity plot is going to be interesting to see when we get to combine all our data. Would we expect the EW to change periodically? I thought the total flux stayed pretty constant in these systems and the main effect is changes in the shape at ~constant EW due to velocity changes. Morel et al for example used changes in skewness and the centroid to measure CIR in this star using the HeII 4686 line
http://www.stsci.de/wr134/pdf/morel1999.pdf

Cheers
Robin.

----- Original Message ----- From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 3:30 AM
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134



Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/

Autor:  Thomas Eversberg [ 31. Juli 2013, 12:37:30 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags: 

Yes, our team in Montréal surely will take that into account. EW should not be affected in first order. The presented EW variability is not very strong with respect to the error bars (how are they estimated?).

Thomas

Autor:  Tony Moffat [ 31. Juli 2013, 14:49:00 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Beautiful observations, Thierry! But don?t expect a strict periodicity. Despite a strict rotation period, we suspect that the bright spots that form on the hydrostatic surface of the star come and go on timescales of a few rotations, introducing a scatter in the phasings of the light curve variations, which can partly hide the underlying periodicity of 2.3d. This period was found previously through intense monitoring, but never for as long as we are doing in this campaign. Keep it up!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 10:30 PM
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/

Autor:  thierry Garrel [ 31. Juli 2013, 21:00:45 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi,
last four WR134 spectra of the night showed a new increasing hump on the red part of the line. It should have disappeared this night.. Robin, thanks for the paper, but i'm still monitoring the line with Ew,  an easy to do approximation of the behavior of this now complex line, thanks John, my neihghbor (!), to have warn us.
 Observing sessions are quite long but exiting with such surprise., Yesterday we lost again 2H with a declination problem, now recurrent, and still no autoguiding. Our night assistant, Pedro, is very experienced, a good observer too with the 1.5m TCS in infrared photometry and has finally succeed to restart the telescope.
Attached is also the active 4686 line profile variation of our 4 nights here. I have reduced all night profiles of others WR stars, available if some wants to compared, but have no time to analyze it. We are about to send raw data to Montréal. Running with multilingual Audela for acqusition and real time reduction would have gave to the Teide teams here a good appreciation of their work and some exiting moments like the one we live. I have corrected some bad things in the data acquisition guidelines, specially Thar overexposition, led flat leading to memory effect and error in the continuum.
 
Cheers
Thierry




2013/7/31 Tony Moffat <fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)>
Zitat:
Beautiful observations, Thierry! But don?t expect a strict periodicity. Despite a strict rotation period, we suspect that the bright spots that form on the hydrostatic surface of the star come and go on timescales of a few rotations, introducing a scatter in the phasings of the light curve variations, which can partly hide the underlying periodicity of 2.3d. This period was found previously through intense monitoring, but never for as long as we are doing in this campaign. Keep it up!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 10:30 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat






Dateianhänge:
multiplot_WR134_4686.png
multiplot_WR134_4686.png [ 12.38 KiB | 11731 mal betrachtet ]
wr134_4686.png
wr134_4686.png [ 20.49 KiB | 11731 mal betrachtet ]
multiplot.WR134_5411.png
multiplot.WR134_5411.png [ 12.4 KiB | 11731 mal betrachtet ]
ew_courbe_WR134_5411.png
ew_courbe_WR134_5411.png [ 4.05 KiB | 11731 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Robin Leadbeater [ 31. Juli 2013, 23:56:22 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi Thierry,

I don't think the current behaviour is particularly unusual. Here are a couple more examples of the variability in this line as reported in my test spectra from last year and one of yours from 2011

http://spektroskopieforum.vdsastro.de/f ... 65_579.png
http://spektroskopieforum.vdsastro.de/f ... 12_206.png

Robin

----- Original Message -----
From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 8:10 PM
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134



Hi,
last four WR134 spectra of the night showed a new increasing hump on the red part of the line. It should have disappeared this night.. Robin, thanks for the paper, but i'm still monitoring the line with Ew, an easy to do approximation of the behavior of this now complex line, thanks John, my neihghbor (!), to have warn us.

Autor:  Tony Moffat [ 01. August 2013, 00:51:46 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Beautiful observations, Thierry. There is a lot going on in the spectra: quasi-periodic CIRs and stochastic clumping, so the 2.3d periodicity may not be obvious. Only when we look at all the data over 4 months will we really know what?s going on. Just keep up the good work!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 3:10 PM
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi,
last four WR134 spectra of the night showed a new increasing hump on the red part of the line. It should have disappeared this night.. Robin, thanks for the paper, but i'm still monitoring the line with Ew, an easy to do approximation of the behavior of this now complex line, thanks John, my neihghbor (!), to have warn us.
Observing sessions are quite long but exiting with such surprise., Yesterday we lost again 2H with a declination problem, now recurrent, and still no autoguiding. Our night assistant, Pedro, is very experienced, a good observer too with the 1.5m TCS in infrared photometry and has finally succeed to restart the telescope.
Attached is also the active 4686 line profile variation of our 4 nights here. I have reduced all night profiles of others WR stars, available if some wants to compared, but have no time to analyze it. We are about to send raw data to Montréal. Running with multilingual Audela for acqusition and real time reduction would have gave to the Teide teams here a good appreciation of their work and some exiting moments like the one we live. I have corrected some bad things in the data acquisition guidelines, specially Thar overexposition, led flat leading to memory effect and error in the continuum.

Cheers
Thierry




2013/7/31 Tony Moffat )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Beautiful observations, Thierry! But don?t expect a strict periodicity. Despite a strict rotation period, we suspect that the bright spots that form on the hydrostatic surface of the star come and go on timescales of a few rotations, introducing a scatter in the phasings of the light curve variations, which can partly hide the underlying periodicity of 2.3d. This period was found previously through intense monitoring, but never for as long as we are doing in this campaign. Keep it up!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 10:30 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/

Autor:  thierry Garrel [ 01. August 2013, 01:46:51 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Ah yes Robin i remember. I was not thoroughly following such a star and now with many spectra per night it seems to me more interesting. For sure a four month campaign will deliver a lot of results, some unexpected. Live science is always exiting. Now the Calima is strong but under the dust limit and we lost thirty percent of signal. Still remain a lot more than in my garden. The seeing is average for Teide observatory between 0,8" and 1,2". Yesterday we had a coronal sky, you could make a total eclipse of the sun only with a penny. Nightsky during daylight, we were on the moon.
Tony you said that you were surprised by John'hump while observed before. I missed something ?


T



2013/8/1 Tony Moffat <fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)>
Zitat:
Beautiful observations, Thierry. There is a lot going on in the spectra: quasi-periodic CIRs and stochastic clumping, so the 2.3d periodicity may not be obvious. Only when we look at all the data over 4 months will we really know what?s going on. Just keep up the good work!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 3:10 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi,
last four WR134 spectra of the night showed a new increasing hump on the red part of the line. It should have disappeared this night.. Robin, thanks for the paper, but i'm still monitoring the line with Ew, an easy to do approximation of the behavior of this now complex line, thanks John, my neihghbor (!), to have warn us.

Observing sessions are quite long but exiting with such surprise., Yesterday we lost again 2H with a declination problem, now recurrent, and still no autoguiding. Our night assistant, Pedro, is very experienced, a good observer too with the 1.5m TCS in infrared photometry and has finally succeed to restart the telescope.
Attached is also the active 4686 line profile variation of our 4 nights here. I have reduced all night profiles of others WR stars, available if some wants to compared, but have no time to analyze it. We are about to send raw data to Montréal. Running with multilingual Audela for acqusition and real time reduction would have gave to the Teide teams here a good appreciation of their work and some exiting moments like the one we live. I have corrected some bad things in the data acquisition guidelines, specially Thar overexposition, led flat leading to memory effect and error in the continuum.

Cheers
Thierry





2013/7/31 Tony Moffat )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Beautiful observations, Thierry! But don?t expect a strict periodicity. Despite a strict rotation period, we suspect that the bright spots that form on the hydrostatic surface of the star come and go on timescales of a few rotations, introducing a scatter in the phasings of the light curve variations, which can partly hide the underlying periodicity of 2.3d. This period was found previously through intense monitoring, but never for as long as we are doing in this campaign. Keep it up!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 10:30 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))


Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134





Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat





Autor:  Robin Leadbeater [ 01. August 2013, 02:31:00 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

It sounds amazing. It is great that you are able to get such nice results. The seeing must be a real advantage in helping our small spectrographs perform well on much larger scopes. I have only been up on Teide once, many years ago when I was on honeymoon. I was not so interested in astronomy then though ;-) Now my doctor tells me I should not go to such altitudes :-(

Zitat:
Tony you said that you were surprised by John'hump while observed before. I missed something ?
I just mentioned that I also saw it in my measurements from 2 weeks ago

http://spektroskopieforum.vdsastro.de/f ... 18_137.png

Clears Skies!
Robin

Autor:  Tony Moffat [ 01. August 2013, 03:43:06 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Indeed, I had forgotten how large the spectral variations can be in WT134. And I wanted to be sure that the big hump was actually real and not due to some instrumental effect. The other spectra show that it is indeed real. But I repeat that we won?t know what it all means until we can digest the whole 4 months of data (perhaps even more, if some observers wish to continue into late September and more).

Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 7:58 PM
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Ah yes Robin i remember. I was not thoroughly following such a star and now with many spectra per night it seems to me more interesting. For sure a four month campaign will deliver a lot of results, some unexpected. Live science is always exiting. Now the Calima is strong but under the dust limit and we lost thirty percent of signal. Still remain a lot more than in my garden. The seeing is average for Teide observatory between 0,8" and 1,2". Yesterday we had a coronal sky, you could make a total eclipse of the sun only with a penny. Nightsky during daylight, we were on the moon.
Tony you said that you were surprised by John'hump while observed before. I missed something ?


T



2013/8/1 Tony Moffat )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Beautiful observations, Thierry. There is a lot going on in the spectra: quasi-periodic CIRs and stochastic clumping, so the 2.3d periodicity may not be obvious. Only when we look at all the data over 4 months will we really know what?s going on. Just keep up the good work!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 3:10 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi,
last four WR134 spectra of the night showed a new increasing hump on the red part of the line. It should have disappeared this night.. Robin, thanks for the paper, but i'm still monitoring the line with Ew, an easy to do approximation of the behavior of this now complex line, thanks John, my neihghbor (!), to have warn us.

Observing sessions are quite long but exiting with such surprise., Yesterday we lost again 2H with a declination problem, now recurrent, and still no autoguiding. Our night assistant, Pedro, is very experienced, a good observer too with the 1.5m TCS in infrared photometry and has finally succeed to restart the telescope.
Attached is also the active 4686 line profile variation of our 4 nights here. I have reduced all night profiles of others WR stars, available if some wants to compared, but have no time to analyze it. We are about to send raw data to Montréal. Running with multilingual Audela for acqusition and real time reduction would have gave to the Teide teams here a good appreciation of their work and some exiting moments like the one we live. I have corrected some bad things in the data acquisition guidelines, specially Thar overexposition, led flat leading to memory effect and error in the continuum.

Cheers
Thierry





2013/7/31 Tony Moffat )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Beautiful observations, Thierry! But don?t expect a strict periodicity. Despite a strict rotation period, we suspect that the bright spots that form on the hydrostatic surface of the star come and go on timescales of a few rotations, introducing a scatter in the phasings of the light curve variations, which can partly hide the underlying periodicity of 2.3d. This period was found previously through intense monitoring, but never for as long as we are doing in this campaign. Keep it up!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 10:30 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))


Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134





Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/

Autor:  thierry Garrel [ 01. August 2013, 04:35:37 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

That's clear Tony. More is to come, amateurs are enthusiastic people to feed by astrophysics and live science.Now seeing is down to 0,4", but the Calima is up to us. Milky way has vanished, banned from our sky, lowering on the horizon in a yellow hazy sky. Seems more looks like at what we used to know.
Robin, results you obtained from your own modest observatory deserve amateur community in much more manner than us. Destiny is sometimes cruel but force talent.
back to observations


t



2013/8/1 Tony Moffat <fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)>
Zitat:
Indeed, I had forgotten how large the spectral variations can be in WT134. And I wanted to be sure that the big hump was actually real and not due to some instrumental effect. The other spectra show that it is indeed real. But I repeat that we won?t know what it all means until we can digest the whole 4 months of data (perhaps even more, if some observers wish to continue into late September and more).

Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))
Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 7:58 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134





Ah yes Robin i remember. I was not thoroughly following such a star and now with many spectra per night it seems to me more interesting. For sure a four month campaign will deliver a lot of results, some unexpected. Live science is always exiting. Now the Calima is strong but under the dust limit and we lost thirty percent of signal. Still remain a lot more than in my garden. The seeing is average for Teide observatory between 0,8" and 1,2". Yesterday we had a coronal sky, you could make a total eclipse of the sun only with a penny. Nightsky during daylight, we were on the moon.

Tony you said that you were surprised by John'hump while observed before. I missed something ?



T



2013/8/1 Tony Moffat )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Beautiful observations, Thierry. There is a lot going on in the spectra: quasi-periodic CIRs and stochastic clumping, so the 2.3d periodicity may not be obvious. Only when we look at all the data over 4 months will we really know what?s going on. Just keep up the good work!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 3:10 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134




Hi,
last four WR134 spectra of the night showed a new increasing hump on the red part of the line. It should have disappeared this night.. Robin, thanks for the paper, but i'm still monitoring the line with Ew, an easy to do approximation of the behavior of this now complex line, thanks John, my neihghbor (!), to have warn us.

Observing sessions are quite long but exiting with such surprise., Yesterday we lost again 2H with a declination problem, now recurrent, and still no autoguiding. Our night assistant, Pedro, is very experienced, a good observer too with the 1.5m TCS in infrared photometry and has finally succeed to restart the telescope.
Attached is also the active 4686 line profile variation of our 4 nights here. I have reduced all night profiles of others WR stars, available if some wants to compared, but have no time to analyze it. We are about to send raw data to Montréal. Running with multilingual Audela for acqusition and real time reduction would have gave to the Teide teams here a good appreciation of their work and some exiting moments like the one we live. I have corrected some bad things in the data acquisition guidelines, specially Thar overexposition, led flat leading to memory effect and error in the continuum.

Cheers
Thierry





2013/7/31 Tony Moffat )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Beautiful observations, Thierry! But don?t expect a strict periodicity. Despite a strict rotation period, we suspect that the bright spots that form on the hydrostatic surface of the star come and go on timescales of a few rotations, introducing a scatter in the phasings of the light curve variations, which can partly hide the underlying periodicity of 2.3d. This period was found previously through intense monitoring, but never for as long as we are doing in this campaign. Keep it up!

Thanks, Tony

From: thierry Garrel (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))

Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 10:30 PM
To: fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]) (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==%3E)vds-astro.de[/email]))


Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134





Hi all, John,some report from the Teide on 5411.
Short terms variations are observed too with a high confident. But no periodic behavior has been observed so far, only three nights. We can suspect such from Ew evolution but we need more observations.


Something to follow


Thierry

2013/7/30 John Strachan )vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de ([email]fg-spek-convento(==>)vds-astro.de[/email]))>
: Thanks for the comments Tony.
After a cloudy weekend it cleared on Monday :0) Results of last nights 4 spectra attached showing gradual filling in on blue side of the peak









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/




Tony Moffat









Thierry Garrel
Observatoire de Fontcaude, Montpellier, France
SpectroBlog http://gabalou.canalblog.com/





Tony Moffat





Autor:  Thomas Eversberg [ 01. August 2013, 10:57:14 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags: 

Hi Robin!
Zitat:
The seeing must be a real advantage in helping our small spectrographs perform well on much larger scopes.
And a respective focal reducer. :)

Cheers, Thomas

Autor:  John Strachan [ 08. August 2013, 22:50:45 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags: 

Some very nice spectra you have there Thierry - despite the weather and technical problems you have been having.

I attach a picture of some spectra I have taken whilst in France last week - showing the changes taking place in the He II line each day I could take spectra.

I'll upload all the spectra and support files when I get access to the ftp site.

cheers

John

Dateianhänge:
wr134.png
wr134.png [ 27.74 KiB | 11411 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Berthold Stober [ 08. August 2013, 23:13:26 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags: 

Hi,

please how do you calibrate the spectra at this wavelength area?

Cheers berthold

Autor:  John Strachan [ 08. August 2013, 23:18:32 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

I use the brightest lines from the neon lamp in the region and calibrate using ISIS

To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134
From: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de
Date: Thu, 8 Aug 2013 23:13:27 +0200

Hi,

please how do you calibrate the spectra at this wavelength area?

Cheers berthold

Autor:  Lothar Schanne [ 09. August 2013, 15:06:55 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags: 

Hello Berthold,

find on Robins wabpage usable weak lines of the Neon lamp:
http://www.threehillsobservatory.co.uk/ ... opy_12.htm

Autor:  Berthold Stober [ 09. August 2013, 19:00:30 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Thank you, Lothar


Cheers
Berthold

Herzlicher Gruss Berthold

Am 09.08.2013 um 15:06 schrieb Lothar Schanne <fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)>:

Zitat:
Hello Berthold,

find on Robins wabpage usable weak lines of the Neon lamp:
http://www.threehillsobservatory.co.uk/ ... opy_12.htm



Herzliche Grüße / best regards

Lothar

www.astrospectroscopy.eu





Autor:  Robin Leadbeater [ 09. August 2013, 22:20:50 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Here are the lines I have been using for this campaign with LHIRES and a 1200 grating. A 3rd order fit seems to work well but I have not tried ISIS to see if it can detect them automatically.

Cheers
Robin

----- Original Message ----- From: Lothar Schanne (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Friday, August 09, 2013 2:06 PM
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134



Hello Berthold,

find on Robins wabpage usable weak lines of the Neon lamp:
http://www.threehillsobservatory.co.uk/ ... opy_12.htm



Herzliche Grüße / best regards

Lothar

Dateianhänge:
CIII_5696_Ne_calibration.png
CIII_5696_Ne_calibration.png [ 42.16 KiB | 11345 mal betrachtet ]
HeII_5411A_Ne_Ar_calibration.png
HeII_5411A_Ne_Ar_calibration.png [ 32.68 KiB | 11345 mal betrachtet ]

Autor:  Berthold Stober [ 09. August 2013, 23:52:04 PM ]
Betreff des Beitrags: 

Hi Robin,

do you have in the lhires a neon-argon lamp for calibration at 5400 A?

Cheers
Berthold

Autor:  Robin Leadbeater [ 10. August 2013, 03:15:48 AM ]
Betreff des Beitrags:  My attempt at WR134

Hi Berthold,

It is just the standard neon lamp but there is a small amount of argon contamination in it as well. Lines 1,2 are Ne. Lines 3,4,5 are Ar

Cheers
Robin


----- Original Message ----- From: Berthold Stober (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
To: fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de (fg-spek-convento@vds-astro.de)
Sent: Friday, August 09, 2013 10:52 PM
Subject: [fg-spek] Re: My attempt at WR134



Hi Robin,

do you have in the lhires a neon-argon lamp for calibration at 5400 A?

Cheers
Berthold

Dateianhänge:
LHIRES_1200_orange_Ne_green_Ar.png
LHIRES_1200_orange_Ne_green_Ar.png [ 14.06 KiB | 11331 mal betrachtet ]

Seite 1 von 1 Alle Zeiten sind UTC+02:00
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Limited
https://www.phpbb.com/